‘A tax on people of faith’

(UMNS) — If Congress drastically cuts the federal food stamp program, religious institutions will not be able to fill the gap for hungry families. That was the message delivered by religious leaders from southeastern states who participated in an Oct. 30 media briefing.

The leaders expressed their concerns the same day as the first public meeting of the Congressional farm bill conference committee in Washington, D.C. The U.S. House version of the farm bill would cut the U.S. Dept. of Agriculture’s Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), the nation’s primary food-assistance program, by $39 billion.

’As the SNAP benefits are decreasing, we’re seeing an increase in individual needs in our area.’

“As the SNAP benefits are decreasing, we’re seeing an increase in individual needs in our area,” said Bishop Paul Leeland, who represents 650 congregations in the United Methodist Alabama-West Florida Conference. “The majority of these people are children and older adults.”

Congregations are already engaged in direct response to communities, and specifically hunger, across the South, explained Bishop Ken Carter of the United Methodist Florida Conference. “While tithing is decreasing, giving by local churches to human need is not decreasing, but increasing,” he pointed out. “This is due to the faithfulness and sacrifices of women and men who listen to sermons and respond with God’s compassion. “At the same time, the dramatic cuts to SNAP and the corresponding proposed shift of responsibility are beyond the capacity of faith communities to address.”

Other United Methodists who supported the media briefing are Bishop Hope Morgan Ward, North Carolina Conference; The Rev. Diane Baldwin, pastor, Georgetown-Chunchula (Ala.) United Methodist Church; Bishop James Swanson, Mississippi Conference; and Bishop William McAlilly, Nashville Episcopal Area (Memphis and Tennessee conferences).

On Nov. 1, the benefits of all 48 million people in the SNAP program were cut across the board an average of 8%, said James Weill, president of the Food Research & Action Center in Washington, D.C.

Every southeastern state exceeds the U.S. national child poverty rate of 22.6%, according to the action center’s latest analysis. The SNAP caseload in eight southeastern states has increased 65.9% during the past five years.

Taking up the slack

Religious leaders criticized the assumption of some federal lawmakers that faith communities can pick up the cost of cuts to SNAP. To make up for the proposed reductions, each religious congregation in the United States would need to increase its food assistance by nearly $15,000 a year for the next 10 years, totaling more than $145,000, according to Bread for the World.

Religious groups … would have to pick up the added responsibility … in what ‘represents a tax on people of faith.’

“Florida is undergoing a tremendous impact from unemployment,” said the Rev. Russell Meyer, executive director, Florida Council of Churches, and a clergy member of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. “If SNAP is cut, as proposed … the estimate is one out of three Florida families will face food insecurity at some point during the week.”

Religious groups in Florida, particularly suburban churches, would have to pick up the added responsibility for feeding the hungry in what “represents a tax on people of faith,” Meyer argued.

The price tag on feeding America’s poor doesn’t change just because the government shirks its duties and expects religious groups to fill in, Meyer pointed out. “It’s shifting a real cost in society onto a particular subset of society who feels the burden,” he explained. “Many people who don’t go to church feel the burden as well.”

A lawmaker disconnect

Some lawmakers eager to slash food stamp funding seem to have a disconnect with what is happening in their own communities, the religious leaders asserted.

Bishop Hope Morgan Ward of the United Methodist North Carolina Conference said the key is to work on relationships with those in need.

Even some church members, Ward admitted, do not know the name of one child in living in poverty. United Methodists in her state, she said, are engaged in increasing relationships with people who need SNAP assistance. “We do not allow people we know and live with to go without food,” the bishop said.

Unable to meet the demand

The Rev. D. Scott Weimer, senior pastor, North Avenue Presbyterian Church in downtown Atlanta, said there is plenty of interfaith cooperation to assist those in need but an “increased strain in our ability to feed hungry people.”

Weimer’s own congregation hosts a day-care center and preschool for homeless children. The congregation has discovered that many of the children who take advantage of free school lunch programs “are not eating on weekends and holidays.”

Although religious leaders are encouraging churches to adopt schools to provide weekend meals, Weimer said, “what we are discovering is we can’t keep up even with that demand.”

The Rev. Connie Shelton, director of Communications for the United Methodist Mississippi Conference, told how the congregation at Heritage United Methodist Church in Hattiesburg discovered the importance of its backpack food ministry: A teacher described the excitement of one fifth-grade boy about having the gift of food for the weekend.

Shelton said Mississippi residents already are generous to those in need, but can’t absorb the gaps the proposed food stamp cuts will create. “Cutting a program without changing a system and culture is not the answer,” she emphasized.

Seniors also are suffering, said the Rev. Eric Mount, of the Kentucky Council of Churches’ Justice Advocacy Commission, who has observed both senior citizens and the programs that help feed them struggling to stay afloat. Some seniors, he said, are “having to choose between paying their [medical] co-pay and buying food.”

Editor's note: Linda Bloom is a United Methodist News Service reporter based in New York.

Other faith leaders who supported the briefing call are the following:

  • The Rev. Gregory Walton, president, The Florida-Georgia District of The Lutheran Church – Missouri Synod
  • The Rev. Robert Schaefer, Bishop of the Florida-Bahamas Synod of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America
  • The Rev. Dr. Russell Meyer, executive director, Florida Council of Churches
  • Bishop Terry Allen White, Episcopal Diocese of Kentucky
  • The Rev. Dr. Eric Mount, Justice Advocacy Commission, Kentucky Council of Churches
  • Father Patrick Delahanty, executive director, Catholic Conference of Kentucky
  • The Rev. Julie Pennington-Russell, pastor, First Baptist Church, Decatur, Ga.
  • The Rev. Dr. D. Scott Weimer, senior pastor, North Avenue Presbyterian Church, Atlanta, Ga.
  • The Rev. J. George Reed, executive director, North Carolina Council of Churches
  • The Rev. Betty Meadows, Transitional General Presbyter, Presbytery of Charlotte, N.C.
  • The Rev. Roland Hayes, Pastor, Overlook Christian Church, Mobile, Ala.
  • Marilyn King, M.A., LBSW, executive director for Catholic Social Services, Archdiocese of Mobile
  • The Rt. Rev. Andrew Waldo, VIIIth Bishop, The Episcopal Diocese of Upper South Carolina
  • The Rev. Dr. Herman Yoos III, Bishop of the South Carolina Synod, Evangelical Lutheran Church in America
  • The Rev. Warner Durnell, Presbytery Executive for the Presbytery of Middle Tennessee
  • Suzii Paynter, executive doordinator, Cooperative Baptist Fellowship, Atlanta, Ga.
  • Rabbi Laurie Rice, Congregation Micah, Brentwood, Tenn.

Letter to the Editor